2015 Calvin Awards: Best Screenplay
By Reagen Sulewski
February 13, 2015
As a group of scribes, obviously we here at BOP prioritize the written word. However, when it comes to screenplays, it's much more than just dialogue that makes them work. For our list of top screenplays in the last year of film, many excelled because of that dialogue, but others were champions of plot, setting, theme and/or character. While there's a heavy overlap between this list and our Best Picture group – how could there not be? – several films jump around in order based on our preference for that element of the film.
Our top honors then, go to The Grand Budapest Hotel (making the biggest jump of any film in the top 10) and its script by Wes Anderson, his first solo effort as a writer. Clearly he shouldn't have been dragging that dead weight around all these years, as this delightful farce and a paean to days of civility and service... which probably never really existed, but what the hell. In addition to Anderson's trademark rapid-fire and stylized dialogue, we're gifted with a well-lived in world with its own set of bizarre, yet eminently logical rules and customs, adhered to as a matter of honor, and which inform and drive the plot of the film in its own right. And speaking of the plot, it's a labyrinthine odyssey, structured like a Russian doll, which is always hiding one more layer or twist. The entire thing should have been completely ridiculous, but comes together as a marvelous tapestry of word play, spectacular characters and pure absurdity.
Second place goes to what's turned out to be everyone's second favorite film of the year, Birdman, and its four writers. While its stylish direction gets a lot of attention, the film's script is also an amazing bit of characterization, of an actor looking to rediscover his own talents and show the world he's more than the shallow figure they make him out to be. It's also a clever meta-narrative on the nature of performance, and the relationship of an actor to his work and his audience. Add to that, Birdman also contains more than a handful of “wait, did... did that just happen?” moments that had us admiring the audacity of one of the year's best scripts.
Third place goes to indie darling Whiplash, and its portrayal of a pas de deux between an aspiring jazz drummer and his domineering drill sergeant of a conductor. Playing almost as a straight-up thriller, Whiplash's script winds up the tension throughout, catching its lead character in an ever-shrinking trap of his psychological torturer's making, reaching a breaking point that we really should have seen coming. None of it would have been half as effective without the script's brilliant setup of its main duo, two opposing wills, one with a terrifying arsenal of abuse at the ready. We felt every moment of tension in this film thanks to its perfectly crafted story.
Adapting a hugely popular book to the screen can often be a challenge, in that its big notes are often known by most of its audience. The translation can often turn into a “greatest hits” version of the book, sapping it of its energy and verve. However, Gillian Flynn adapted her own novel, Gone Girl, to the screen in a masterful fashion, and for which we've honored it with fourth place. The book's many twists survived to the screen with their impact intact, and elucidated what made this just an addicting story.
The highly complex puzzle box of a script for Interstellar finishes fifth in our balloting. Christopher and Jonathan Nolan deftly navigated the complex time travel of their sci-fi film, while giving us fantastic characters at its center to make us care about their fate. While we might have done without one sidetrack that didn't entirely help the film, it's probably quibbling given the end result.
Sixth spot goes to Selma, which excelled in telling the many personal stories of the civil rights movement, as well as getting to the heart of an important moment in U.S. history.
Another complex sci-fi film finds its way to this list, with Edge of Tomorrow hitting seventh thanks to its Groundhog Day-meets-Alien premise, and its endlessly clever iterations on the premise.
Our sole top 10 screenplay that didn't make our top 10 picture list is Nightcrawler, which lands in eighth. The razor-sharp media satire and portrait of a dangerous adrenaline-junkie and fame seeker brought to mind the likes of Network.
Boyhood's monumental effort of a screenplay hits in ninth spot, on the strength of telling a coherent coming-of-age story over 12 years of real time – while its episodic nature means the film like a real narrative drive, the overall story of the film tells an enormously compelling tale.
Lastly, the endlessly earnest and hilarious script for The LEGO Movie rounds out our top 10 screenplay list, taking what could have been a D.O.A. premise into a clever meditation on the nature of childhood and imagination. While we expected comedy, we didn't expect a genuinely thought-provoking debate on what makes a toy.
2015 Calvin Awards
Best Overlooked Film
Best Supporting Actor
Best Supporting Actress
Best TV Show
Best Use of Music
See our 2014 Awards
See our 2013 Awards
See our 2012 Awards
See our 2011 Awards
See our 2010 Awards
See our 2009 Awards
See our 2008 Awards
See our 2007 Awards
See our 2006 Awards
See our 2005 Awards
See our 2004 Awards
See our 2003 Awards
See our 2002 Awards
||The Grand Budapest Hotel
||Edge of Tomorrow
||The LEGO Movie