New at BOP: Review: Matrix Resurrections Movie Review: Moonfall Movie Reviews: Scream The #1 Movie in America November Forecast The Many Saints of Newark October Forecast New Trivia Question All site updates Share & Save   Tweet Print this column

Some of the people who perished on the mountain are given more focus than others, which either has the effect of or is the reason why their eventual fates are given weightier significance. This makes for effective technique in the moment - and two of these moments, both involving nothing more than the effect of gravity, are probably the most unmanning of any movie this year so far - but it also means that the lives and deaths of real individuals are pushed aside and minimized in favor of theme or narrative for another real individual, and something about that seems a little callous to me.

The movie is at its most effective not when it’s involved in minor character drama or obligatory byplay and setup - again, shades of ’90s disaster films - but in moments like the one on the poster, involving the ladder across a seemingly bottomless chasm in the Khumbu Icefalls. There’s the simple reality of incredible danger and risk, and the people who are willing to experience that danger and risk for whatever reason.

The people at Base One who shepherd these individuals and expeditions acquaint themselves with this danger and risk as readily as the climbers do, except they don’t necessarily know what’s going on or where anyone is moment to moment. A late sequence with two of these individuals, played by Emily Watson and Sam Worthington, confront the nature of their job head-on. These moments may or may not be true to life, but they are authentic, tense, and emotional.

Kormákur uses the tactic of shooting as much of the movie as possible on location (the real Everest Base Camp was used, as well as other locations scattered throughout Nepal), and making the transition to effects gradually. He also doesn’t call attention to anything that would be too obviously set-bound. The end result is a film with an eerily realistic tint to even its most calamitous moments. A climber gingerly traverses a foot-wide path with no ropes over a drop of thousands of feet, and the camera courteously points straight down at him so that we can see the drop whenever we’d care to look. Is it CGI? Matte work? I didn’t care; I got vertigo. Other moments are similarly dizzying, and this is not a movie for those with a fear of heights.

I liked the movie, but I have a feeling that I liked it more because it doesn’t really do anything wrong and because it frames a tragedy with responsibility and clarity than because it particularly does anything right. It certainly doesn’t do anything outside the structural or stylistic or characterization realm of a well-made disaster film, and because of that it achieves a certain degree of effectiveness and respect. You will not miss any crucial aspect of the event or the effect on the people involved if you read about it, so the major reason to see the movie would be the visceral sequences on Everest itself. See it in IMAX, if you can.

Continued:       1       2