New at BOP: Review: Matrix Resurrections Movie Review: Moonfall Movie Reviews: Scream The #1 Movie in America November Forecast The Many Saints of Newark October Forecast New Trivia Question All site updates Share & Save   Tweet Print this column

Edwin Davies: I think it has come along at a perfect time to capitalize on the late summer malaise that tends to settle over the box office when people have had their fill of action movies. The season is winding down, kids are going back to school, and adults are starting to hanker for films that don't feature the world being destroyed. The Butler is exactly the kind of middlebrow, prestige pic that might get swamped in the height of awards season but can clean up amidst the dregs of blockbuster season, and the timing could not have been more perfect.

In addition to scheduling, which can help a film break out but is rarely the sole factor, it's got an inspirational story based on historical events - which, in turn, offers opportunities for a lot of bizarre stunt casting - which appeals to not just adult audiences, but also African-American and religious ones. All three are pretty poorly served by Hollywood in general and especially in the summer months, so The Butler has a lot going for it from a demographic point of view.

In terms of awards contention, the film has received mixed reviews, which is not a death knell as far as Oscar chances go but does mean that it might get shut out of the major categories, except maybe the acting ones. Then again, it depends on how the rest of the year plays out. If there is a weak field this year, I could see The Butler getting a lot of attention. If not, it'll be an afterthought, albeit a successful one.

David Mumpower: I would add that I have always believed that mid-August is a terrific point on the movie schedule to release an awards contender. Generally, audiences have been overwhelmed with three months of popcorn fare by this point. A substantive project represents a refreshing change of pace. Now, 2013 has featured a better class of blockbusters than is usually the case but the thought process is still valid. I also believe that The Butler offers a tantalizing combination for a movie of this type. It has a lot in common with The Help but there is also a nice touch of Forrest Gump as well.

Kim Hollis: This is a marvelous performance that has been helped by a number of contributing factors. First off, the controversy about the name got the movie mentioned in entertainment headlines for several weeks running in advance of the film's release. Next, we have the casting, which brought in a variety of top-notch performers whose presence suggests a certain amount of gravitas. There are five Academy Award winners in the cast (Forest Whitaker, Vanessa Redgrave, Cuba Gooding Jr., Jane Fonda and Robin Williams) and two other actors who were nominated for Oscar (Oprah Winfrey, Terrence Howard). Even though she's not on daytime TV anymore, Oprah still has devoted fans and followers. Her presence is extremely important. Finally, you have an under-served crossover demographic that always seems to shock Hollywood when they come out to support fare like this. I really don't know why some small or mid-level studio doesn't just go ahead and focus on this niche, though I suppose Lionsgate is sort of doing that with Tyler Perry to some degree.

As far as awards go, I don't think it's too early at all to say this is an early contender for several awards. Its critical reviews are very similar to what The Help did during the same time frame a few years ago and the word-of-mouth is similar as well. Whitaker is sure to be in the mix for Best Actor, and I actually think Danny Strong has a real shot for screenplay although I recognize that's a tough category most years. Depending on how large the Best Picture pool is, I do think The Butler has a fantastic chance. Remember - it's the Weinsteins. They make awards happen for their movies. I guess it just depends which of their biopics they push come Oscar time - this one, the Mandela one, or the Grace Kelly story. My guess is that The Butler is the most marketable of the three.

Continued:       1       2