Movie Review: The Dark Knight Rises

By Edwin Davies

July 23, 2012

I'm not sure why we got all dressed up to come to this warehouse.

New at BOP:
Share & Save
Digg Button  
Print this column

Wayne is drawn out of seclusion after Selina Kyle breaks into his house and steals something from his safe, though she is really after something else entirely, and his fascination with her leads him to a larger conspiracy, one that requires him to don the cape and cowl again, and eventually leads him to face Bane. As played by Tom Hardy (though the mask means we only see his face once, in flashback; the rest of the time he is heard in distractingly clear voiceover), Bane is a terrifying figure of imposing physical prowess and fierce, efficient intellect. In that respect, he represents the most formidable opponent that Batman has yet faced, since not only is he capable of implementing a dizzyingly complex plan that fundamentally alters Gotham, one that even overshadows the crazy machinations of The Joker since it is carried out with such cold, meticulous care, but he is also an unstoppable force capable of dealing immense damage: he has the power to break Batman both physically and spiritually, and as such The Dark Knight Rises winds up being the first Batman film in which it feels like the character is actually in danger.

It's also probably the best that Christian Bale has been in the role over the course of the series, since he has to go the furthest distance; charting a downfall and a rise that, even over two and a half hours, feels like it is only barely covered. The film also finds new, incredibly poignant ground to mine from the relationship between Bruce and Alfred (Michael Caine), who wind up at loggerheads over whether or not Bruce should become Batman again. As a man who has already buried two members of the Wayne family and just wants the surviving one to be happy, Caine gives a moving and at times heart wrenching performance that nicely draws upon the relationship that the audience has developed with him over the three films.

Owing to the number of new characters that the film has to introduce - alongside Bane and Kyle (who, interestingly, is never actually referred to as Catwoman) there's John Blake (Joseph Gordon-Levitt), an idealistic cop who plays a large role in getting Batman back in the game, Miranda Tate (Marion Cotillard), a member of the board of Wayne's company who wants him to invest in sustainable energy projects, and Foley (Matthew Modine), a senior detective who is gunning for Commissioner Jim Gordon's (Gary Oldman) job - as well as the need to establish what has happened to series veterans like Oldman, Caine and Morgan Freeman, the opening act feels awkward and more than a little messy. This isn't a particularly huge problem for the film overall, though, since even as it clunkily gets into gear, it manages to include a jaw-dropping sequence in which an aircraft is torn apart in mid-air by another aircraft, and perfectly establishes the combative/flirtatious relationship between Batman and Kyle. However, it does result in the film lacking the clear focus of either of its predecessors, as Wayne becomes a side-character until he is ready to get back to his old tricks, in the process leaving the film without a central character for much of its first hour.


As the story progresses, and it becomes apparent just how crazy and ambitious Nolan and his collaborators intend to make their film, the messiness of the film becomes a large part of its charm. Much as was the case with The Dark Knight, the story unfolds in ways which are bold, exciting and, most importantly, unpredictable. It is fully possible to guess what is going to happen in broad strokes - particularly if you are the sort of person who has read any of the speculation that has built up around the film in the last four years - but the events themselves unfold in a way which dwarfs even the expectations one might have after the first two films. On his last go-round, Nolan unashamedly aims to create an epic, and once all the threads start converging in its sublime third act, the messy sprawl of The Dark Knight Rises starts to take a more defined shape. It still seems rougher around the edges than the first two films, but it also reaches a lot further than either in terms of scope, ambition and sheer audacity.

Whilst The Dark Knight Rises is ultimately a sloppier film than any of Nolan's previous efforts, both in and out of the Batman franchise, it is also one that paints on a much broader canvas. Since every aspect of the film is turned up a notch, the flaws are intensified just as much as its strengths are, but the things that it does well it does so very well that the flaws don't really amount to much. It works as spectacle, delivering visceral and astonishing moments that are shocking and surprising, it works as allegory, raising questions about contemporary society and the disparity between wealth and poverty, and it works as a grand finale to a great trilogy. It fumbles a little in the beginning and the middle, but absolutely sticks the landing, which makes for a wonderfully satisfying ending. Good luck to whoever takes over the series after Nolan and co. depart.

Continued:       1       2



Need to contact us? E-mail a Box Office Prophet.
Tuesday, September 25, 2018
© 2018 Box Office Prophets, a division of One Of Us, Inc.