New at BOP: Review: Matrix Resurrections Movie Review: Moonfall Movie Reviews: Scream The #1 Movie in America November Forecast The Many Saints of Newark October Forecast New Trivia Question All site updates Share & Save   Tweet Print this column

Michael Lynderey: I think they made a mistake bowing to Captain America: Civil War, and moving Batman Vs. Superman from the first weekend of May to late March. Looking at it from almost any perspective, B V. S will be the much bigger film. I think it can easily win the year (yes, in March!) and gross something like $600 million. This looks huge. Epic. An untamed box office behemoth. Who wouldn't want to see it?

Captain America 3, on the other hand, will probably just play as a marked-down version of Avengers 2. That film will finish with roughly $460 million, and so I think Cap 3 will probably do something like $350 million. Clearly, B V. S will reign supreme over that and any other challengers.

David Mumpower: While I have no top ten lists to offer, I concur with one of Kim's points. I want to preface this by saying that I think I was the only critic in North America who named Zombieland the best movie of that year. I also had The Social Network and Adventureland in my top 10 for their years of release. I think it's fair to say that I like Jesse Eisenberg as a rule. This trailer makes me reconsider that opinion. I've never seen someone so actively campaign for a Razzie, and I've watched almost all of Nic Cage's movies.

As for the rest of it, I've made the argument before that the people at Warner Bros. have no idea how to make a Batman movie. And the problem they face is that compared to the other DC Comics adaptations, Batman is Casafreakinblanca. Man of Steel was an unmitigated disaster of a film, a tightly wound ball of cinematic hatred disguised as an action flick. It had no redeeming value other than creating a national anthem for homicidal maniacs too young to enjoy American Psycho. Rather than move away from that downward trajectory, Zack Snyder, someone I've perennially defended in this space, has slammed down the gas pedal to speed up his cinematic collision course with enmity. He's just about ready to pass Mark Millar as the Spite King of Comics. I can't even tell that Batman is in this movie between all the mass murders and random career quotes from Eisenberg. I...respectfully disagree that it'll be the #1 movie of the year. Having Batman in the title doesn't cure enough ills here.

Suicide Squad

Ben Gruchow: I bought Jared Leto as the Joker, on the strength of his brief appearance at the end of the trailer. He's the most effective element of the whole thing, and he gives it a sense of identity and connection that will, I think, be fairly crucial to the movie's reception. Judging by the crowd's reaction to him, I'm not alone.

David Ayer, as writer and director, has an interesting resume for this type of film, and the presence of a longtime collaborator of his as DP should at the very least give Suicide Squad cohesion.

Max Braden: For me, this trailer is all about Harley Quinn. She's the most expressive of the bunch. I'm also interested to see what Will Smith brings to he group. The trailer has a style reminiscent of Christopher Nolan's Batman movies. But that's a double-edged sword; now that we have Heath's Joker, I forget about Nicholson's Joker and I don't want to see someone else attempt it. The comic book crowd may want to see Leto bring the Joker to life, but he's the point in the trailer I like least.

Continued:       1       2       3       4