On Digitizing Hoffman

By Edwin Davis

February 7, 2014

One of our favorites, and sorely missed.

New at BOP:
Share & Save
Digg Button  
Print this column
In addition to the many heartfelt tributes that have appeared in the wake of actor Philip Seymour Hoffman's untimely death, not to mention the frankly unsettling way in which the news media has picked over the circumstances surrounding his death, one of the more callous questions that has been asked over the last few days, admittedly by people who should probably look up the meaning of the word "tact," has been, "What about the Hunger Games sequels? Won't someone please think of the Hunger Games sequels!"

Hoffman had appeared as the Head Gamemaker Plutarch Heavensbee in The Hunger Games: Catching Fire and was close to finishing his work on the final film, The Hunger Games: Mockingjay Part 2, when he passed away last week from an apparent overdose, leaving some doubt over how the filmmakers would work around the scenes that he had left. An early account suggested that most of the scenes could be rewritten, or that they would use body doubles to give a sense of Hoffman's presence without requiring him to be seen too clearly. It was also suggested that they might try to recreate Hoffman digitally, a process that has been used on before on the likes of Gladiator and The Sopranos, and is in no way horrifying, either in concept or practice.

It appears to have been confirmed that this method will be employed in Mockingjay Part 2, if only for a scene or two. In what may be the most redundant sentence you'll read all week, Rob Legato, the effects supervisor for the film, said, "I won't say you could generate a Philip Seymour Hoffman with all the acting ability, but you could certainly replicate him for a shot or two." So his work will continue on the film, even though he'll basically be Gollum at that point.




Advertisement



Now, it's easy to see why the studio would go for this route from a financial standpoint. They've got a wildly successful franchise on their hands and they can't run the risk of shutting down production to figure out the best way to work around the sudden, shocking loss of a colleague. Terrible as it is, they have to keep working, and this seems like the easiest way to keep things moving without having to frantically rewrite the script, possibly delaying the release date of the film, or at the very least throwing the entire production off by several weeks, which could impact the quality of the final product further down the line. It also wouldn't make much financial sense to recast Hoffman's role at this point because he had already shot all his scenes in Mockingjay Part 1, and so little work remained to be done for Part 2 that it would be incredibly weird and costly to replace him, and there would be no easy, textual way of explaining why he suddenly looked so different, as there was in films that lost actors but had more elastic and fantastical realities, like The Matrix Revolutions or The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus.

It also makes some sense from a storytelling point of view; Heavensbee is a pretty major character in the final Hunger Games novel, and it would be difficult to write around his absence. That's not to say that it would be completely impossible, though. It might be feasible to have another character take on some of the heavy lifting for the scenes that remained to be shot, or for some elements of the plot to be shifted around. However, Mockingjay is such a lumpy, uneven book that throwing more complications into it would probably have hurt the story, rather than helped it, and you just bump up against the sheer enormity of the production and the problems of redirecting such a huge endeavor.

So I understand why they chose to "recreate" Hoffman as the least disruptive option, but even if they only do it for a few shots in the final film, it still strikes me as incredibly creepy and unnerving, not just because, as good as CGI is these days, it'll probably look unnatural, but also because you enter into a weird metaphysical area when you start manipulating the images of the recently deceased for profit. It's ghoulish, in the same way that people filming a body being removed from an apartment is, but even more so because the people doing it knew the person in question. Whatever their intentions, it's still immensely disturbing, and only a few steps removed from using Hoffman's body to do the scenes Weekend at Bernie's style. It falls firmly into the area of just because you can do something, doesn't mean that you should.

I mean, there are worse things that they could have done from a technical standpoint. They could have just hired Jesse Plemons and slapped some middle-age makeup on him. They could have brought Tom Cruise in and got him to wear a Philip Seymour Hoffman mask (which admittedly worked pretty well the last time they did it). They could have hired Barry from EastEnders and slapped a blonde wig on him. All of these things would have looked a lot worse than using technology to insert Hoffman into scenes that he had yet to shoot, but they arguably would have been more respectful.


     


 
 

Need to contact us? E-mail a Box Office Prophet.
Thursday, March 28, 2024
© 2024 Box Office Prophets, a division of One Of Us, Inc.