New at BOP: Review: Matrix Resurrections Movie Review: Moonfall Movie Reviews: Scream The #1 Movie in America November Forecast The Many Saints of Newark October Forecast New Trivia Question All site updates Share & Save   Tweet Print this column

David Mumpower: I think Edwin touched upon the key aspect in that American consumers have such goodwill toward Navy SEALs. If Act of Valor could excel while being a truly terrible movie, Lone Survivor should be popular as well. It is a similar concept with a much better story and, you know, professional actors. I would also note that this is the best opening weekend of Mark Wahlberg’s career that did not involve a storm, an ape or a teddy bear. What I find particularly fascinating is that Mark Wahlberg has been in January releases in three consecutive years. Two out of three were solid hits. The one that bombed had the most famous co-star, Russell Crowe. Stuff like this is why everybody in Hollywood is on antidepressants.

Max Braden: Lone Survivor offers a really good mix of realism, straight up action, drama, and a Hollywood treatment. Captain Phillips offers the Hollywood treatment of a real patriotic story, but the lead is a civilian being pushed around with more drama than gunfighting. 47 Ronin and The Legend of Hercules offer more action but it's silly fantasy stuff. This is the kind of role Wahlberg is really good in, and everyone can go and feel pumped up for the right reasons, but also feel something for the characters.

Kim Hollis: The Legend of Hercules debuted this weekend with $8.9 million. What do you think about this result?

Matthew Huntley: Wait, The Legend of Hercules opened this weekend? I guess you could have fooled me, because even though I knew this movie was coming out, I didn't realize it was this weekend. I'm surprised the studio didn't wait a week, in order to capitalize on the MLK Jr. holiday.

In any event, given the movie's lackluster trailer and story, and virtually zero star power, its performance is about in line with expectations. Before long, this movie won't even be a memory. Hopefully the other Hercules movie starring Dwayne Johnson will prove more formidable.

Felix Quinonez Jr.: I think the result sounds about right for Hercules. I honestly hadn't even heard of this movie before the weekend so obviously the marketing wasn't a priority for the studio. It had terrible reviews and just about zero star power. Obviously the result is terrible but it shouldn't be a surprise to anyone.

Edwin Davies: I'll echo Felix and Matthew by saying that I wasn't aware that this was even coming out this weekend until I saw it mentioned in the Weekend Forecast. I saw no ads for it, only vaguely know Kellan Lutz from Twilight (I all honesty I think of him more for being a reference in a couple of episodes of 30 Rock) and didn't even know he was in it. I'm not even entirely convinced that this movie actually exists, so if anything, 8.6 million dollars sounds like too much.

Jay Barney: I was aware the film was coming out, but based on the trailer I saw, I had little interest in spending my money on it. Most movie goers felt the same way, as this one had a very week opening. It is not going to last very long in theaters, and will be out of the top 10 within a couple of weeks.

Max Braden: Ditto all the comments so far; something slipped up in the marketing. I recently knew this was coming but didn't have a good sense that it was this weekend. I also didn't have a good sense of the story despite hearing the trailers on TV, which means they didn't hold my attention or sell it well enough. The bottom line is that the reviews have ranked this as a poor product, and it's hard to sell crap. I thought of this as something like another Immortals (opening at $32 million), which wasn't a selling point for me. Still, I think if they had given the marketing some more lead time they might have been able to squeeze more money out of it. This isn't good news for Kellan Lutz, who's obviously trying to step forward from Twilight side character to lead actor.

David Mumpower: It needed more Kevin Sorbo. I also found myself thinking something strange over the weekend. ABC Family aired the 1997 Disney version of Hercules on Sunday. If 275,000 people watched that airing, more people saw a 16-year-old animated version of the movie than the new one that cost $70 million to produce. That’s brutal.

Tim Briody: How does Renny Harlin continue to find work? He's Uwe Boll with a better agent, apparently.

Continued:       1       2