Indie Watch
The Broken Circle Breakdown
By Dan Krovich
February 20, 2014
BoxOfficeProphets.com
The Broken Circle Breakdown
When you think Foreign Film Oscar nominee from Belgium, great American bluegrass music is probably not the first thing that comes to mind, but The Broken Circle Breakdown delivers the goods. The film tells the story of Elise and Didier. She owns her own tattoo shop while he is a bluegrass musician. They meet and fall in love at first sight, she joins the band, and they have a child. When their daughter becomes ill, it places an intense strain on their relationship, stemming largely from the fact that he is an anti-religion atheist, and while she may not be a devotee of organized religion, she certainly has a strong spiritual side.
The film is told non-chronologically with moments of high highs and low lows interspersed with musical interludes. The music functions much like the music in the Oscar-winning Once where the music informs the emotions and plot of the film, but because the characters are the musicians, the performances are organic. While the film could be classified as a musical, it’s not one where characters break out into song out of nowhere. The songs are powerful. I wouldn’t consider myself a fan of bluegrass or anything close to knowledgeable about the genre, but the songs quickly cut to the soul. Even if you don’t see the movie, the soundtrack is worth a listen, but within context the songs are even elevated.
The genre that the film most falls into is the kitchen sink melodrama. Although there is a complete lack of camp that sometimes can characterize melodrama, the film does tend to repeatedly hit you with the big moments both uplifting and devastating. The effect of presenting them out of order adds to the impact of certain scenes where having seen the future can inform the underlying emotions of the present. It’s not as disjointed as something like 21 Grams and there is a stronger linear through line, allowing the scenes to be arranged skillfully and maximize their effect.
The Broken Circle Breakdown is almost a perfect film, but there is one misstep that comes across as jarring and does seem to break the flow of the movie. While not completely out of nowhere, the film takes a short detour into political issues and social commentary that doesn’t completely seem to fit with the rest of the movie. The film otherwise is so intensely personal and intimate that the foray into this territory, while not out of character, does distract.
That criticism is a minor quibble, however, in an outstanding film. The Broken Circle Breakdown is perhaps one of the bigger pleasant surprises in the Oscar nominations. Much criticism has been directed at the way the Oscars handled the Foreign Film category when certain “sure things” were ruled ineligible, were not selected to represent their country, or did not make the final cut. Those quirks may keep some notable films out of the nominations, but they also allow surprises like The Broken Circle Breakdown to break out. While unlikely to take home the big prize, the film deservingly garnered much more attention than it ever would have received otherwise. It’s a worthy film for your attention as well.
Available at Amazon
Available at iTunes
Available at Vudu
Editor's note: if you have Amazon Prime, The Broken Circle Breakdown is available to stream for free. Use the above link for direct access.
New releases for February 21st
Almost Human: Mark vanished two years ago in a flash of light that suggested alien abduction. He has now returned, but he may not be all human. His return is accompanied not so coincidentally with a string of bloody murders. Director Jon Begos pays homage to '80s horror in this microbudget sci-fi horror film.
Barefoot: Scott Speedman plays Jay, the black sheep of a wealthy family. He is without direction and has a gambling problem. Owing money to some unsavory characters, he hatches a plot to get that money from his disapproving family. He meets Daisy (Evan Rachel Wood), who is a patient at a mental institution where he is doing community service. Raised in isolation, Daisy is naïve and childlike and possibly schizophrenic, but Jay hopes to pass her off as his girlfriend and a sign that he has matured in hopes that will open his father’s wallet. Of course, the fake relationship begins to blossom into real affection as Daisy opens Jay’s heart.
Available at Vudu
In Secret: Based on the 19th century novel Therese Raquin by Emile Zola, In Secret is a period thriller about obsessive passion. Elizabeth Olsen plays Therese, a woman in a loveless arranged marriage to her cousin Camille (Tom Felton). When Camille’s friend Laurent (Oscar Isaac) arrives, Therese’s passions are immediately stirred and the two begin an illicit affair. As they become more consumed with each other they hatch a plot to be together which can only happen with Camille out of the way.
Omar: Palestine earns its second Oscar nomination for Foreign Film, and both of the nominations are for films by director Hany Abu-Assad. Paradise Now earned a nomination in 2006 (it lost to Tsotsi from South Africa) and now Omar is an Oscar nominee as well. Omar, the titular character, is a Palestinian baker who must illegally scale the dividing wall just to visit his girlfriend. When he and his friends kill an Israeli soldier and he is captured, he is given the option of turning informant in exchange for his freedom in this tense thriller.
The Wind Rises: Legendary Japanese animated film director Hayao Miyazaki makes what is being declared his final film with The Wind Rises. The film is a highly fictionalized biopic of Jiro Horikoshi, an engineer who was responsible for designing many of the Japanese fighter planes for World War II. Fascinated by flight but unable to fly due to his near sightedness, the film chronicles key events in Jiro’s life, including a major earthquake in 1923 and his rise through a major engineering company. The film has received artistic acclaim but has also garnered some controversy as some have criticized making a film that celebrates a man who designed “killing machines.”